By Krista Barnes, Founder of We Do SEO, LLC.
A good agency conversation should leave you understanding the work, not just impressed by a report. As the founder of We Do SEO, I want a prospective client to ask what we will actually change, who owns the accounts, and how we will tell whether the work is helping. Those questions matter with any provider.
Key takeaways
- Request concrete deliverables and responsible owners.
- Keep business accounts under the business’s control.
- Expect honest reporting and no guaranteed placement.

Ask what happens in the first month
Request the order of operations: baseline, audit, fixes, content priorities, and access. Ask which tasks the agency performs and which require your developer or internal team. A list of “optimizations” without owners or dates is not a plan.
Ask what evidence supports a recommendation
The agency should be able to show why a page, business profile, or tracking issue matters. Be cautious with guaranteed rankings, claims of secret AI access, or large batches of near-duplicate pages.
Put this into practice
One practical example
If a proposal includes AI visibility, ask to see the actual prompts, dates, sources, and accuracy checks behind the score. A single flattering answer is not a measurement program.
Keep ownership and reporting clear
The business should know who owns the domain, analytics, ad accounts, profiles, content and logins. Agree on what a qualified lead means and how reporting will distinguish organic, paid, Maps and AI referrals where possible.
Related guidance from We Do SEO
Explore
SEO pricing and plans, and contact We Do SEO.
Frequently asked questions
Should I hire based only on a lower monthly price?
Compare the scope, implementation support, communication and measurable outcomes alongside cost.
Can an agency guarantee AI citations?
No responsible agency can guarantee how an independent answer system will respond to every query.
What access should the agency have?
Grant the level needed to perform agreed work while keeping business ownership, recovery methods and billing with the client.
Next step
If you want to apply this to your own website, contact We Do SEO for a review of your pages, local presence, and measurement. We will identify what to improve first and explain why it matters for your business.